One Game, Two Different Stories: Hobart Decides Whether This Series Belongs to Beardman or Banton
Perth was Australia's, by seven wickets with 159 balls to spare. Adelaide was England's, by 135 runs. Now the series goes to Bellerive Oval at 1-1, with Mahli Beardman likely back for Australia and an England batting line-up that has just remembered how good it can be.
Two games, two very different answers
Few series swing as hard as this one has in four days. In Perth on Friday, England were bowled out for 131 in 33.4 overs, and Australia knocked the runs off in 23.3 overs. The man who did the damage was Mahli Beardman, 21 years old and playing on his home ground, who took 6 for 24 on debut, the best figures by an Australian in a first ODI. Forty-eight hours later in Adelaide, England made 355 for 6 and bowled Australia out for 220. That is the beauty of a three-match series: nobody gets to settle in.
So it comes down to Hobart, on Wednesday, in a day-night game that starts at 2:30 PM local time. The winner takes the ODI series, and then both sides head to the MCG for the first of five T20Is on Saturday. Australia have won the last three bilateral ODI series between these two. England have not won one against Australia since 2018. History leans one way; the last game leaned the other.
Australia: Beardman's return, and a batting line-up to steady
Beardman sat out Adelaide. It was not a selection call so much as care: he is coming back from a stress fracture, and after a long flight and a short turnaround, Australia chose to rest him. Reports from Adelaide said he is in line to return here. Riley Meredith, who was brought into the squad for the last two games, took his place on Sunday and would be the most likely man to make way.
The bigger worry for Mitchell Marsh may be the batting. In Adelaide, Matthew Renshaw made 63 and Cameron Green 64, but no one else got going, and at 127 for 5 the chase of 356 was already slipping away. Gus Atkinson took four wickets, with Joe Root taking two sharp catches at slip, and that is the kind of thing that can happen again if the Hobart pitch has a bit of early life. Marsh himself made 50 off 30 balls in Perth, and if he and Travis Head get Australia off to that sort of start, England will feel the pressure quickly.
Xavier Bartlett took 3 for 72 in Adelaide and will lead the attack with Spencer Johnson, who took 3 for 42 in Perth. Adam Zampa holds the middle overs. A possible XI, if Beardman is fit: Travis Head, Mitchell Marsh (c), Cooper Connolly, Josh Inglis (wk), Matthew Renshaw, Cameron Green, Jack Edwards, Xavier Bartlett, Adam Zampa, Spencer Johnson, Mahli Beardman. If Australia decide to take no risk with him, Meredith may keep his place.
England: Banton's case, and three dropped catches to forget
Tom Banton made 121 off 99 balls in Adelaide and reached his hundred in 86 deliveries, with 12 fours and four sixes. He was player of the match. With Jacob Bethell out with a long-term knee injury, Banton has the opening spot beside Ben Duckett, and he is making it hard to take back: 540 runs at an average of 60 in nine innings since he moved up. Jordan Cox (67 off 49), Joe Root (62) and Will Jacks (54 not out off 40) filled in around him. That was the England batting people expected to see in Perth.
The bowling was sharp too. Atkinson took 4 for 28, Sam Curran took two in two balls, and Liam Dawson took 2 for 41. Dawson continues to be preferred to Adil Rashid as the main spinner, and Sonny Baker replaced Jamie Overton in Adelaide. But England dropped three simple catches, including Renshaw and Green before their fifties. In a decider, that is the kind of thing that could cost them.
A winning side is rarely changed, so a possible England XI is the same one: Ben Duckett, Tom Banton, Joe Root, Harry Brook (c), Jordan Cox (wk), Sam Curran, Will Jacks, Liam Dawson, Gus Atkinson, Sonny Baker, Jofra Archer. Rashid might come in if England read the pitch as one for wrist spin, but it would be a surprise.
The numbers that matter
| Series | 1-1 after two games |
| 1st ODI, Perth | England 131 (33.4 overs) lost to Australia 132 for 3 (23.3 overs) by 7 wickets |
| 2nd ODI, Adelaide | England 355 for 6 beat Australia 220 (44.3 overs) by 135 runs |
| Mahli Beardman | 6 for 24 on debut in Perth, Australia's best figures on ODI debut |
| Tom Banton | 121 off 99 in Adelaide; 540 runs at 60 in nine innings since moving up to open |
| Gus Atkinson | 4 for 28 in Adelaide |
| Toss | Australia won both and chose to bowl both times |
| Bilateral ODI series | Australia have won the last 3 against England; England last won one in 2018 |
Pitch and conditions — Hobart's cool, honest surface
Bellerive Oval tends to give a little to the seamers early, especially with the breeze off the Derwent and the cooler Tasmanian air, and then settles into a good batting pitch once the ball gets older. The boundaries are not big, so a team that keeps wickets in hand can push hard in the last ten overs. Under lights, the new ball in the second innings may do a bit more, which is one reason Australia chose to bowl first in both games so far.
That makes the first ten overs of each innings the part to watch. If Beardman and Bartlett find movement, England's top order will be tested the way it was in Perth. If Duckett and Banton get through it, a total around 300 could be very hard to chase. Wind and cold can also make life difficult for spinners holding the ball, something Zampa and Dawson will both have to manage.
The verdict
This is very close. Australia have the better recent record against England and, if Beardman plays, the bowler who has already broken this batting line-up once. England have momentum, a batting order that has just made 355, and an opener in Banton who looks like he believes he belongs.
Our lean is towards England, very narrowly, because their batting looks the more complete of the two right now. But if Australia win the toss again, bowl first and find early movement, the Perth story could easily be repeated, and nothing about this series suggests either side will let the other relax.
Australia vs England, 3rd ODI, Bellerive Oval, Hobart — Wednesday, November 18, 2:30 PM AEDT / 9:00 AM IST. Unlock CricIntel Pro for ODI projections and match predictions.
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →