CricIntel
Cricket NewsAustraliaSandpapergateNews

Bancroft just did the forum's job in public, and named the bowlers too

Hours after Cricket Australia promised a private room and no new sanctions, Cameron Bancroft told everyone that he held back the truth in 2018 and that the whole team knew. The scorecard from Port Elizabeth shows exactly whose spell he is talking about.

November 18, 2026|5 min read|CricIntel Editorial

What Bancroft wrote

For eight years the official story of Sandpapergate had three names in it. On Wednesday one of those three said the story was false, and that he helped make it false.

Cameron Bancroft has written a 4,000-word account of the 2018 tour of South Africa. It ran first in The West Australian and was then sent to other outlets, as ESPNcricinfo reported. His central claim is simple: it was not just him, Steve Smith and David Warner who knew about the sandpaper. It was the whole team.

The bigger admission is about himself. Bancroft says he did not tell Cricket Australia's 2018 investigation everything. He held back when the sandpaper was first used, how long it went on and who else knew, and he says he did that to protect the investigation and the people around him.

He also says what pushed him to write. According to the excerpts carried by AAP, the final straw was Pat Cummins' press conference last week, which left him feeling angry, betrayed and alone.


When I was questioned during Cricket Australia's investigation, I did not give a complete and truthful account.
Cameron Bancroft, in The West Australian, via ESPNcricinfo

The names in the account

This is not a vague "everyone knew". Bancroft puts people in rooms. He says the plan grew out of a tea-break talk on day two of the second Test in Port Elizabeth about getting more reverse swing, that bowling coach David Saker was part of it, that head coach Darren Lehmann was there, and that it was Warner who first raised sandpaper, per ESPNcricinfo.

On the field, he says, he kept asking the fast bowlers whether the ball was going: Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh, plus wicketkeeper Tim Paine. He says they gave him feedback, that at one point he was told to stop because it was becoming too obvious, and that Saker praised his work at a team meeting the next morning. He also says it was Saker who told him during the Cape Town Test to do more with the sandpaper.

One detail cuts against the idea that nobody objected. Bancroft recalls the team's media manager, Kate Hutchison, saying it was wrong and walking out of the discussion.


I recall conversations with all the fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough.
Cameron Bancroft, in The West Australian, via ESPNcricinfo

The Port Elizabeth spell, wicket by wicket

South Africa before the collapse 155 for 2, 2nd Test, Port Elizabeth, March 2018
Hashim Amla, 56 b Starc, 155/3 (66.4 overs)
Dean Elgar, 57 c Paine b Hazlewood, 155/4 (67.6 overs)
Faf du Plessis, 9 lbw b Mitchell Marsh, 179/5 (75.3 overs)
Theunis de Bruyn, 1 lbw b Mitchell Marsh, 183/6 (77.4 overs)
The spell 4 wickets for 28 runs in 11 overs
Cummins in that innings 3 for 79 (Markram, Rabada, Philander), none in the spell
How the tour ended Lost at Port Elizabeth by 6 wickets; lost at Cape Town by 322 runs after 107 all out

The CricIntel view

We pulled the Port Elizabeth scorecard to put Bancroft's words next to the cricket. The "4 for 28" he talks about is real and easy to find. South Africa were 155 for 2 in their first innings. Eleven overs later they were 183 for 6. Those four wickets went to Starc (Amla, bowled), Hazlewood (Elgar, caught by Paine) and Mitchell Marsh, who trapped Faf du Plessis and Theunis de Bruyn lbw. Every wicket in the spell went to a bowler Bancroft names, and the one catch went to the keeper he names.

A scorecard cannot prove anyone knew anything. Reverse swing at Port Elizabeth is not proof of cheating, and Bancroft has now admitted he once gave investigators an incomplete story, which his critics will use against him. But it does change the question. The bowlers' long-standing position is that they did not know. Bancroft's position is that he was asking them, over by over, whether his work was helping. Those cannot both be true, and the men involved are not retired. Cummins, Starc and Hazlewood are the core of the Test attack that meets New Zealand from December 9. Marsh captains the ODI side that is playing England this week.

The timing is the real damage for Cricket Australia. It announced a voluntary, confidential forum with no new sanctions on Wednesday. Within hours, a sanctioned player had told the public that CA's own 2018 investigation was built partly on his incomplete evidence. A forum that cannot compel anyone, and has not promised to publish, now has to weigh a confession that is already public. Our view: CA can no longer say there is no new information. It has a new account, from a primary witness, against its own report. The forum's terms of reference, due within days, need a deadline, a published finding and a clear invitation to Saker, Lehmann and the four bowlers. Anything less and the forum becomes the place where Bancroft's account goes to be ignored.


I took the bullet for everybody, and it was my choice ... However, in 2018 not the entire truth was told.
Cameron Bancroft, in The West Australian, via AAP

Where it goes next

No response from Cummins, Saker, Lehmann or the other bowlers was in the reports we read. That is the next thing to watch. Cummins spoke for 68 minutes last week, and Bancroft has now answered that press conference directly, so silence may be hard to keep. The other date to circle is November 21 at the MCG, when Australia's white-ball side play England again and the first questions will be about Port Elizabeth, not the series.

Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?

Sources

Free to play

Wanna beat your friends?

Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.

Up to 90 points a match

Play Game →