Banton has stopped keeping Bethell's seat warm. Nine innings say it's his
Tom Banton followed his 121 in Adelaide with a polite claim on England's opening spot. The numbers back the claim, but they also show the one thing still missing before Wednesday's decider in Hobart.
A stand-in who no longer sounds like one
Tom Banton was only opening for England because Jacob Bethell's right knee gave way. After his 121 off 99 balls in Adelaide, he is not talking like a man waiting to hand the job back.
Asked whether the spot was now his to keep, Banton gave a careful yes, in an interview with BBC Test Match Special that ESPNcricinfo reported. He also said Sunday was his first visit to the Adelaide Oval, despite three Big Bash seasons with Brisbane Heat. Not a bad way to say hello.
The century set up England's 355 for 6, their highest ODI total in Australia, and a 135-run win that made the series 1-1 two days after they were bowled out for 131 in Perth.
I'd like to think so. Cricket's a funny old game. It can change very quickly.Tom Banton, to BBC Test Match Special, via ESPNcricinfo
The captain is already on board
Harry Brook did not need to be asked twice. Speaking after the match, as AFP reported, the England captain called Banton's knock fantastic and pointed to the depth that let Jordan Cox and Will Jacks push the total past 350 after Banton fell at 212 for 4.
That matters, because the opening job was supposed to be Bethell's. He was given it against India in July, made 91 at Lord's in the decider and won the series. He has not played a competitive match since, and he flew home from Perth last week after a setback in his recovery from knee surgery.
Bants played a fantastic innings and the depth that we have meant that we could go on and get that big 350.Harry Brook, England captain, via AFP
Banton's nine ODI innings since September
| v Sri Lanka at home (Sep) | 10, 73, 126 |
| Tri-series in Pakistan (Oct) | 57, 50, 4, 74 |
| In Australia (Nov) | 25 in Perth, 121 in Adelaide |
| Total | 540 runs at 60.00, two hundreds, six scores of 50 or more |
| Opening stands with Duckett in Australia | 24 in Perth, 19 in Adelaide |
| Bethell's last ODI | 91 v India at Lord's, July; no competitive match since |
The CricIntel view
Six scores of fifty or more in nine innings is not a hot streak; it is a body of work. Before Australia, Banton had 394 runs at 56.28 in seven innings. He has added 146 in two more and pushed the average to exactly 60. Only three of the nine innings ended below 30, and one of those was a 25 on a Perth pitch where England were bowled out for 131. Bethell's case rests on one excellent series in July and a knee that has not let him play since. On current evidence, this is not a debate. Banton keeps the job until he loses it on the field.
But here is the part nobody is talking about: the opening partnership itself has not worked in Australia. Banton and Ben Duckett put on 24 in Perth and 19 in Adelaide. Duckett made 9 in both games. Adelaide's 355 came from Banton and Joe Root adding 137 for the second wicket, not from the openers. Banton is winning the argument as an individual. The pair is not winning the new-ball battle yet.
That is exactly the test Hobart sets on Wednesday. Our preview has Mahli Beardman, rested in Adelaide after his 6 for 24 in Perth, in line to return, and Bellerive usually helps the seamers early before it flattens out. In Perth, Xavier Bartlett beat Banton first ball and later had him caught behind. If Banton gets through the first 10 overs against Beardman and Bartlett, England go in with the edge. If the openers fall cheaply again, a 1-1 series can still turn into Australia's fourth straight bilateral ODI series win over England.
One more thing for the selectors. England go to a 50-over World Cup in South Africa next year. A settled opener who averages 60 and can also bat in the T20I middle order is rare. When Bethell is fit, the smart question is not who opens, but where else Bethell bats.
What happens next
The decider is at Bellerive Oval, Hobart, on Wednesday, November 18, starting at 9:00 AM IST. England travel via Melbourne on Monday and train on Tuesday. After that, both sides go to the MCG for the first of five T20Is on Saturday.
Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?
Sources
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →