Bethell trades the IPL for his knee, and it costs him almost nothing
A second knee operation rules Jacob Bethell out of the Johannesburg Test and he will not enter December's IPL auction. Nine IPL games in two seasons made this an easy call. Missing Test cricket is the part that hurts.
One more operation, one less tournament
Last week Jacob Bethell's knee sent him home from Perth before England's white-ball tour began. On Tuesday the bill got bigger.
An ECB spokesperson told Sky Sports that Bethell will have surgery on his right knee this week and is out of the tour of South Africa: three Tests from December 17 in Johannesburg, then three ODIs in January. Sky says no return date has been set.
The IPL is gone as well. Royal Challengers Bengaluru released him on retention day, and ESPNcricinfo learned that he will not put his name into December's auction, a decision taken after talking to the ECB. Josh Tongue, ESPNcricinfo added, is also staying out of the auction despite interest from several franchises, so he can spend April and May getting ready for the Ashes and the World Cup.
Unfortunately, he's had a recurrence of a knee injury and at this stage, there's a considerable amount of uncertainty about his return to play and his injury and rehab timeline.Mo Bobat, RCB director of cricket, via ESPNcricinfo
Who fills the gap
ESPNcricinfo expects England to open in Johannesburg with Emilio Gay and Ben Duckett, with Jordan Cox keeping No. 3. A replacement batter will come from the England Lions squad that is also touring South Africa. Sky says that call will be made once the team is there. ESPNcricinfo names Ollie Pope, Ben McKinney and James Rew as the options.
In the 50-over side the problem has already solved itself. Tom Banton made a match-winning hundred at Adelaide on Sunday, his sixth score of 50 or more in eight innings by ESPNcricinfo's count. Bethell was meant to open there. He will now come back to find that job taken.
We rate him very highly, and he's been sensational both on and off the field.Andy Flower, RCB head coach, in a statement reported by Sky Sports
Jacob Bethell by the numbers (ESPNcricinfo career figures)
| IPL for RCB | 9 matches, 163 runs, avg 18.11, SR 140.51, HS 55, no overs bowled |
| Tests | 9 matches, 579 runs, avg 34.05, HS 154, 8 wickets at 31.87 |
| ODIs | 24 matches, 712 runs, avg 33.90, SR 90.58 |
| T20Is | 36 matches, 786 runs, SR 150.86 |
| Last match | 91 and 1 for 49 vs India at Lord's, July 19, 2026 |
| Days out by the end of the SA Test series (Jan 7) | 172 |
| Days out by the MCG 150th anniversary Test (Mar 11) | 235 |
The CricIntel view
Pulling out of the IPL sounds like a big sacrifice. For Bethell it is close to the cheapest decision he could make.
Look at what the IPL has actually given him. His ESPNcricinfo record shows nine matches for RCB over two seasons, two of them in 2025. He has 163 runs at 18.11 with one fifty, and he has not bowled a single over. That average is his lowest in the four T20 leagues he has played: 21.28 in the Hundred, 21.70 in the Blast and 24.37 in the BBL. His IPL strike rate of 140.51 is ten runs below his T20I mark of 150.86. RCB used him as a bench batter. A knee that needs a second operation should not be spending April and May sitting on a bench.
The Test numbers tell a different story. His average of 34.05 across nine Tests includes the 154 he made at Sydney in January. He also bowls, with 8 wickets at 31.87. That is the player England need for an Ashes summer, and he has not played since July 19. By our count he will have been out for 172 days when the Cape Town Test finishes on January 7, and 235 days by the MCG Test on March 11. Sky Sports already lists him as a doubt for that game.
There is a pattern as well. On the same Tuesday, Travis Head (ESPNcricinfo reported that he will miss IPL 2027), Bethell and Tongue have all chosen to stay out of next season. All three gave workload or fitness as the reason, and all three have a Test summer coming. Our read: Bethell's first proper game back is more likely to be for Warwickshire in April than for England in March. The No. 3 spot in England's Test side is Cox's to lose until then.
What to watch
Two things. First, who England call up from the Lions before Johannesburg. Pope being picked as spare batter would mean England want experience. McKinney or Rew would mean they are looking ahead. Second, whether there is any timeline after this week's operation. The best reading of Tuesday's news is that England want him fit for the summer, not rushed back for March.
Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?
Sources
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →