CricIntel
Cricket NewsAustraliaSandpapergateNews

CA built a safe room for Sandpapergate. The men it most needs have no reason to enter

Cricket Australia will hear players' stories in private, punish no one and decide later what the public sees. Khawaja and Warner were unconvinced within minutes, and the four bowlers whose denials matter most open the next Test in three weeks.

November 18, 2026|5 min read|CricIntel Editorial

What CA announced in Hobart

Cricket Australia has finally answered Usman Khawaja's book, and its answer is a room, not a ruling. Interim chair David Boon and chief executive Todd Greenberg called a press conference at Bellerive Oval on Wednesday, a little over an hour before the third ODI against England, and said the board had met the night before and agreed to set up a forum on the 2018 sandpaper affair, as ESPNcricinfo reported.

The rules, as both ESPNcricinfo and ABC News set them out: it is open only to players and staff from the 2018 South Africa tour, it is voluntary and confidential, and an independent person will be named in the coming days along with terms of reference. It is not a new investigation and it cannot sanction anyone. Boon called it a "circuit breaker". The original 2018 report stays private.

The detail that will travel furthest came from Greenberg himself. He said he had now read the 2018 investigation, and that only eight of the 11 Australians who played the Cape Town Test were interviewed for it, according to ESPNcricinfo.


The game is genuinely hurting at the moment. It's not good for anyone. We need to find a path through, and we need some time to heal.
Todd Greenberg, Cricket Australia CEO, via ESPNcricinfo

The pushback took minutes

Khawaja and David Warner were on the broadcast as the press conference went to air, and ABC News reported that both questioned the forum straight away. Neither wants new penalties. Both said they want the whole thing to end. Their objection is about who controls the ending: Greenberg would not commit to publishing anything, saying only that the board would decide what it can disclose once the forum is done.

Khawaja also raised a point CA did not address, per ABC News: that some former staff, as he has heard it, are not allowed to talk about 2018, and that he does not know if they will be free to speak in the forum either.


At the end of the day, if you're going to cherry-pick what is said in this report, the board can choose whatever they want to come in or come out. Are we just going around in a circle?
Usman Khawaja, on the Fox Cricket broadcast, via ABC News

I would have liked an open public inquiry and the people that were there at the time can come forward and speak.
David Warner, on the Fox Cricket broadcast, via ABC News

The Cape Town four, then and now

Australia XI at Cape Town, March 2018 11 players; 8 interviewed by CA's 2018 inquiry (Greenberg)
Of that XI, in Australia's last Test (Newlands, from Oct 27, 2026) 4: Cummins (c), Starc, Hazlewood, Lyon
Mitchell Starc, SA tour 2026 (3 Tests) 15 wickets for 322, average 21.47
Josh Hazlewood (3 Tests) 10 wickets for 273, average 27.30
Pat Cummins (3 Tests) 6 wickets for 328, average 54.67
Nathan Lyon (2 Tests) 6 wickets for 262, average 43.67
The four together 37 of the 47 South African wickets Australia took; series lost 2-1
Australia's Tests from now to the end of the 2027 Ashes 15: 4 v New Zealand from Dec 9, 5 in India, the 150th-anniversary Test, 5 Ashes Tests

The CricIntel view

Look at who has already spoken in public. Khawaja wrote a book. Warner called it 100% accurate. Chadd Sayers said he carried the sandpaper off the field. The people telling the "everyone knew" story have no need of a confidential room; they are on television. The people whose memories are actually in dispute are the bowlers, and the bowlers are not former players with a podcast. They are Australia's Test attack.

We went back to the scorecards. Four of the 11 Australians who played at Cape Town in March 2018 also played Australia's most recent Test, at the same ground, three weeks ago: Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon. On that tour of South Africa the four of them took 37 of the 47 wickets Australia managed, with Starc's 15 at 21.47 leading the way. Cummins, the captain, had his leanest series of the four, 6 wickets at 54.67. They are not a part of this side. They are the side.

That is the flaw in a voluntary, no-sanctions, board-decides-what-to-publish forum. A process with no power to compel and no promise to publish gives the people who have denied everything in public no reason to say anything different in private, and gives everyone else no way to check. Greenberg's own admission, that three of the Cape Town XI were never interviewed in 2018, shows exactly how a confidential process left a gap the first time. The forum might fill that gap, but only the board will know if it did.

It also runs straight into the cricket. Australia's next Test is against New Zealand on December 9, the first of 15 before the end of the 2027 Ashes, five of them in India. The terms of reference do not exist yet. If the forum is still sitting when Cummins walks out for the first Test, every press conference becomes a Sandpapergate press conference, and a captain who already spoke for 68 minutes last week carries it into a series he cannot afford to start badly. Our view: CA should set a finish date before December 9 and promise a published summary now, not after. Otherwise Khawaja's circle is exactly what this becomes.


Where it goes next

The next step is the name of the independent person and the terms of reference, due within days. Watch two things in them: whether former staff are released from any confidentiality obligations to take part, and whether CA writes a publication commitment into the document. If both are missing, Warner's call for a public inquiry will not go away. If both are there, this may yet be the circuit breaker Boon wants.

Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?

Sources

Free to play

Wanna beat your friends?

Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.

Up to 90 points a match

Play Game →