Cummins sent his agent to answer Bancroft. The scorecards say the captaincy isn't the problem
Australia's Test captain has answered a 4,000-word statement naming him with a one-line management note, while the squad for Perth waits. On results, Cummins and the obvious alternative are almost the same captain, which means this is now only about trust.
One line for 4,000 words
Yesterday we wrote that the thing to watch after Cameron Bancroft's statement was whether Pat Cummins would answer it. He has, sort of. Cummins did not speak himself. His management sent a short statement to several Australian outlets, as AFP and The Telegraph both reported, saying Bancroft had raised nothing new.
That is a big bet on a small reply. Bancroft's piece in The West Australian, which Sky Sports put at 4,000 words, does not just repeat Usman Khawaja's line that everyone knew. It describes a tea-break chat at Port Elizabeth, names the bowling coach and head coach, and says he checked with the quicks over by over whether his work on the ball was helping. Cummins' 68-minute press conference on November 13 was a reply to Khawaja's book. It came five days before Bancroft named him.
Whilst we feel for Cam and everything he's been through there's nothing in the statement that hasn't been answered by Pat in his press conference.Pat Cummins' management, as reported by AFP
The pressure on the captaincy
The rest of Wednesday did not help him. According to AFP, an opinion piece in The Australian said Cummins' future as Test captain should be placed under immediate review, and the ABC wrote that his position was now questionable. The Telegraph's Will Macpherson called his future "in major doubt".
The most concrete sign is a date that has moved. AFP reported that Australia's squad for the home Tests against New Zealand had been expected this week and has now been pushed back, with no new date given. Our fixture list has the first Test at Perth Stadium on December 9 and the second at Adelaide Oval on December 17.
Cricket Australia's line, quoted by The Telegraph and Sky Sports, is that it respects Bancroft telling his story and will take time to consider it. Chief executive Todd Greenberg has been firmer on the captain himself.
No, the captain doesn't need to be cleared. No-one's looking to be cleared.Todd Greenberg, Cricket Australia CEO, as reported by AFP
Lehmann asks for time
The other man Bancroft placed in the room was Darren Lehmann, the 2018 head coach. Bancroft wrote that Lehmann and bowling coach David Saker were "certainly present" for the talk, while saying he could not speak for every word. Lehmann has always denied knowing about the plan. Asked about Bancroft's account on ABC radio in Hobart, he said he needed time to take it in, as Sky Sports and AFP reported.
It's only just come to light. I just need to sit back and process all that and work through each allegation.Darren Lehmann, on ABC Radio Hobart, as reported by AFP
Cummins and Smith as Test captains
| Cummins as captain (2021-2026) | 43 Tests: 26 won, 11 lost, 6 drawn (60.5% won) |
| Smith as captain (2014-2026) | 44 Tests: 26 won, 11 lost, 7 drawn (59.1% won) |
| Cummins' bowling as captain | 164 wickets at 23.42 |
| Cummins' bowling not as captain | 164 wickets at 21.59 in 34 Tests |
| Cummins as captain, at home | 21 Tests, 98 wickets at 18.22 |
| Cummins as captain, away | 20 Tests, 55 wickets at 33.29 |
| Cummins as captain, in Tests lost | 11 Tests, 27 wickets at 44.33 |
| Smith's batting as captain | 4,425 runs at 68.07, 18 hundreds |
| Smith's batting not as captain | 6,578 runs at 49.08, 19 hundreds |
| Next Tests | v New Zealand, Perth Dec 9 and Adelaide Dec 17 |
The CricIntel view
Strip out the noise and look at what Cricket Australia would actually be choosing between. We pulled both men's Test records from Statsguru this morning. Cummins has led Australia in 43 Tests and won 26, lost 11 and drawn 6. Steve Smith, the obvious stand-in and the man who has stood in when Cummins has been out, has led in 44 and won 26, lost 11 and drawn 7. Same wins, same losses, one draw apart. If anyone tells you this is a cricket decision, the numbers say it isn't. Neither man is the better results captain.
The job has not cost Cummins much as a bowler either. As captain he averages 23.42 with the ball; without the job it was 21.59. The real split is location: 18.22 at home as captain, 33.29 away. Perth and Adelaide are home, which is exactly where he does his best work. So the cricket case for keeping him through December is strong.
That is why the agent's reply is the wrong move. With results level, the captaincy comes down to authority in the dressing room, and authority is about answering questions yourself. Bancroft did not make a general claim that the press conference already covered. He named a session, a tea break and the bowlers he says he spoke to. "Nothing new" may turn out to be true. But Cummins needs to say it himself and answer those details, as he did for Khawaja.
Our call: we expect Cummins to lead in Perth, because nothing in the record forces a change and Greenberg has said he does not need clearing. But the delay to the squad tells you CA wants the captain to speak first. If the squad is named before he does, CA is choosing the scorecard over the question. On these numbers it could do that and lose nothing on the field, but a lot of trust.
What to watch
Three things. Whether Cummins speaks in person before the squad is named. Whether Lehmann, once he has "processed" it, repeats his old denial word for word or softens it. And whether CA's forum, announced only hours before Bancroft published, invites the people his statement names. The white-ball side meet England at the MCG on November 21, and the Test squad for Perth is now the deadline that matters.
Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?
Sources
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →