CricIntel
Cricket NewsAustraliaUsman KhawajaNews

Khawaja kept a six-year promise. Australia's current dressing room gets the bill

Usman Khawaja says he promised David Warner in 2020 that he would tell the sandpaper story, and admits men still in the Australia side may pay for it. The numbers explain why he thinks the original punishment was the real scandal.

November 16, 2026|4 min read|CricIntel Editorial

The promise, and the timing

Usman Khawaja has now explained the one thing his critics kept asking: why now? His answer, on Antoinette Lattouf's podcast released on Monday and reported by ESPNcricinfo, is a promise he made to David Warner in 2020. He says the two friends barely spoke about it for six years after that, and that he only told Warner what was in his book Sabr two months ago.

He also says he held the chapter back on purpose. He did not want it out while the current team was touring South Africa, and he did not want it leaking. According to AAP, Khawaja insisted Warner had no hand in what was written, and described his conversation with Steve Smith about the book as more awkward.

The podcast was recorded before Pat Cummins' 70-minute press conference on Friday, where the captain called the claim that everyone knew "100% wrong". So this is not a reply to Cummins. It is the argument Khawaja was always going to make.


I've stood up for the three guys who I feel like were treated unfairly. But there's other guys that are still playing in the team right now that there might be some sort of cost.
Usman Khawaja, on the podcast, via ESPNcricinfo

Cricket Australia: a small price

The other new line is about his own future. AAP reported that Khawaja still rates his relationship with CA chief executive Todd Greenberg, whom he spoke to months ago without sharing the chapter's details. If CA now keeps its distance, he called that a small price for what he did.

He also went further than before on the punishment itself. As AAP reported, he called the bans handed to Warner, Smith and Cameron Bancroft "grotesquely overboard", and pointed out that the ICC never sanctioned Warner at all. CA has already said it will not reopen the 2018 investigation.


But I am also not playing the victim here, because I knew what I was getting into. I knew what was coming. I just didn't realise it would be so personal.
Usman Khawaja, on the podcast, via AAP

2018: what the ICC gave, what CA gave

Steve Smith ICC: one-Test ban, 100% match fee. CA: 12 months, plus 2 years without the captaincy
David Warner ICC: no charge. CA: 12 months, and never to lead Australia again
Cameron Bancroft ICC: 75% match fee, 3 demerit points. CA: 9 months
Australia, 10 Tests before Cape Town fallout (Mar 2017 to Mar 2018) Won 6, lost 3, drew 1; 35.29 runs per wicket
Australia, 9 Tests during the bans (Mar 2018 to Mar 2019) Won 3, lost 4, drew 2; 28.13 runs per wicket
Heaviest defeats in that window 492 runs at Johannesburg, 373 at Abu Dhabi

The CricIntel view

Khawaja's "grotesquely overboard" line sounds like loyalty to a childhood friend. The record says he has a case. The ICC, the body that actually polices ball tampering, gave Smith one Test, gave Bancroft a fine and demerit points, and did not charge Warner at all. Cricket Australia turned that into 12 months, 12 months and nine months, and added leadership bans on top. Warner's has never been lifted. In plain terms, the national board punished three players many times harder than the sport's own rule-keeper did.

The cost did not stop with the three players. We pulled Australia's Test results either side of the bans from Statsguru. In the 10 Tests up to Cape Town, they won six and made 35.29 runs per wicket. In the nine Tests played while Smith and Warner were out, they won three, lost four, and made 28.13. That is seven fewer runs every time a wicket fell, and it cost them a first home series defeat to India. The punishment was sold as a cleansing. On the field it was a year of losing.

That is why Khawaja's "cost" line matters now. If, as he and Sayers say, the knowledge was shared, then the price was paid by three men and by the team's results, while the rest carried on. He is not asking for new bans. He is asking for the bill to be split. That is a much harder thing for CA to keep refusing, because it does not need a new investigation, only an admission that the old one stopped at three names.

For the cricket in front of Australia, the timing is awkward rather than dangerous. The ODI series against England is level 1-1 with the decider in Hobart on Wednesday, then five T20Is start at the MCG on Saturday. Smith, per ESPNcricinfo, is unlikely to speak this week before he plays for New South Wales in the Sheffield Shield on Sunday. Every day he stays quiet, Khawaja's version is the only one from the 2018 dressing room with a name and a promise attached to it.


Where this leaves it

Three members of the 2018 squad now say more people knew: Khawaja, Warner and Chadd Sayers. Cummins and Mitchell Starc have rejected the claims. Khawaja's closing pitch is not about blame. It is that the side should take collective responsibility once, so the story stops coming back. Eight years in, it is still coming back.

Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?

Sources

Free to play

Wanna beat your friends?

Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.

Up to 90 points a match

Play Game →