CricIntel
Sitanshu KotakHenry NichollsGlenn PhillipsNews

Kotak says 'not just one day'. India's attack ran out of ideas after 28 overs

India had New Zealand 70/5 in Wellington, then bowled 322 balls without a wicket. Their bowling coach blamed the sun and a soft Kookaburra, and defended leaving out Siraj. The scorecard and Henry Nicholls' Basin Reserve record tell a sharper story.

November 19, 2026|5 min read|CricIntel Editorial

Two days in one

The first Test at the Basin Reserve had two plots on Thursday. In the first, India were brilliant. Jasprit Bumrah bowled Tom Latham with the third ball of the match, and New Zealand were 70/5 inside 29 overs.

In the second, nothing happened for India at all. Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips batted out the remaining 53.4 overs, added an unbeaten 173 for the sixth wicket and took the hosts to 243/5 at stumps. Nicholls finished on 113 from 221 balls, Phillips on 94 from 182.

So the question after play was not whether India bowled well. It was why the bowling stopped working, and whether the XI that left out Mohammed Siraj had a plan for the part of the day it was always going to face.


India's explanation: the sun and the ball

India bowling coach Sitanshu Kotak, speaking after play as reported by the ICC, put it down to conditions. The sunshine dried the pitch faster than even the curator expected, he said, and the Kookaburra's seam had gone tight after 30 or 35 overs. He gave New Zealand's pair credit for what followed.

He also conceded two things. India could have bowled straighter at Phillips, who scored heavily through the off side, and a late chance was spilled when Nicholls pulled a ball to Devdutt Padikkal. Kotak called it "a mix-up" and said India still should have caught it.

Asked about Siraj, he did not budge.


"When you pick an 11, you think about all four or five days it will go on. It is not just one day."
Sitanshu Kotak, India bowling coach, as reported by the ICC

Nicholls: make them keep bowling well

Nicholls, now batting at No. 3 in the slot Kane Williamson used to own, was generous about the morning. He told the post-day press conference that India bowled superbly early and had New Zealand under pressure, the ICC reported, and that the pair's plan was simply to control what they could and force India to keep bowling well all day.

He gave the credit for the stand to Phillips' counter-attack, which, he said in quotes carried by IANS, took pressure off his own role. He also told IANS he has been "quite used to batting anywhere", so the move up from No. 6 changes the timing of his entry more than his method.


"Jasprit Bumrah is Jasprit Bumrah, so we know the challenges that he offers any time he plays. Incredible bowling."
Henry Nicholls, as reported by the ICC

Day 1 in two halves (ESPNcricinfo scorecard)

Overs 0.1 to 28.2 70/5 (Blundell out at 28.2)
Overs 28.3 to 82.0 173/0 in 53.4 overs, 322 balls without a wicket
Jasprit Bumrah 17-5-52-3
Akash Deep 15-5-33-1
Anshul Kamboj (debut) 18-4-57-1
Washington Sundar 16-2-38-0
Prasidh Krishna 16-2-58-0
Everyone except Bumrah 65 overs, 186 runs, 2 wickets
Nicholls / Phillips 113* (221 balls, 14 fours) / 94* (182 balls, 13 fours)

The CricIntel view

Kotak's explanation is honest, and it is also the case against his own selection. If the Kookaburra goes quiet after 30 to 35 overs, then most of every New Zealand innings in this series will be played with a soft ball. Thursday proved it to the over: India's fifth wicket fell at 28.2, and in the next 322 balls they did not take another. That is the stretch an attack has to be picked for, and India picked theirs for the first hour.

The split in the table is stark. Bumrah took 3/52 from 17 overs. The other four bowled 65 overs between them for 186 runs and two wickets, both inside the first 20 overs. Prasidh Krishna went at 3.62 an over, which is actually tighter than his Test career rate of 4.14 across 10 Tests (32 wickets at 32.15, per Statsguru). Nobody was carted. India were simply harmless, and harmless with a soft ball is exactly where an experienced hit-the-deck seamer earns his place. "Not just one day" cuts both ways.

India also ran into the wrong man at the wrong ground. Including Thursday, Nicholls has 1,036 Test runs at the Basin Reserve at an average of 86.33 from 15 innings, with five hundreds and a top score of 200 not out. Everywhere else his 2,435 runs come at 33.36. This was the one venue in the world where letting him settle was most expensive, and India let him go from 29 at lunch to three figures.

Day 2 is now the Test. India need five wickets with a fresh morning, as both Nicholls and Kotak pointed out, and a second new ball that has been available since the 80th over. If they finish the innings for under 300, Thursday's afternoon becomes a footnote. If New Zealand bat into the second session and pass 350, India bat last on a surface that their own coach says is improving, and the Siraj debate will run all the way to Christchurch, where the second Test starts on November 27.


Henry Nicholls in Tests (Statsguru, includes Day 1)

At the Basin Reserve 11 Tests, 15 innings, 1,036 runs, ave 86.33
Hundreds at the Basin Reserve 5 (HS 200*)
At every other ground 80 innings, 2,435 runs, ave 33.36
Career 61 Tests, 3,471 runs, ave 40.83, 12 hundreds

What to watch on Day 2

Watch the first hour, and watch Bumrah's workload. Kotak said Bumrah was rotated through Thursday because he also needs recovery time, which tells you India know how much of this attack rests on one man. Phillips needs six for a second Test hundred. India need one edge to bring in Nathan Smith and the tail, and they need it before the ball goes soft again.

Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?

Sources

Free to play

Wanna beat your friends?

Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.

Up to 90 points a match

Play Game →