Lehmann denies knowing, not the meeting. And the cheating didn't even work
Darren Lehmann's answer to Cameron Bancroft's 4,000 words is that he can't remember the tea-break chat. Cricket Australia's chief executive now says people lied in 2018. The record shows what the pressure was for, and how little it bought.
The coach answers the article
Darren Lehmann has had his say on Cameron Bancroft's 4,000-word account of 2018, and the headline is the same as it was two weeks ago: he did not know sandpaper was being used. He said so on ABC Radio before Saturday's first T20I against England at the MCG, as both ABC News and ESPNcricinfo reported.
The detail is where it gets interesting. Bancroft's article, as ESPNcricinfo quoted it, places Lehmann and bowling coach David Saker in the tea-break conversation on day two in Port Elizabeth, the Test before Cape Town, when David Warner raised the idea of sandpaper. Bancroft also says Lehmann used the walkie-talkie to get a message to Peter Handscomb once the TV pictures had caught him.
I can't remember being present in that conversation. But again, it is eight and a half years ago; you'll have to ask those people.Darren Lehmann, on ABC Radio (via ABC News)
Not a denial, a memory gap
Read that line again. It is not "I wasn't there". It is "I can't remember being there". On the walkie-talkie, Lehmann told ABC Radio it was "all after the fact", because the footage was already on the big screen. That defends what he knew; it doesn't dispute that the call happened.
The rest of the interview was about cost. ABC News reported that Lehmann said he never signed a non-disclosure agreement with CA, that the fallout sent him to "a really dark place" and that it took him three to four years to feel normal. ESPNcricinfo noted he confirmed on Saturday he had been urged to resign in 2018, after the official investigation had cleared him. Asked how he felt about Bancroft, he said "empathy".
That is a softer tone than on November 7, when, as we covered at the time, he brushed off Usman Khawaja's book as "part and parcel of selling books". Bancroft's piece has clearly landed differently.
People said I didn't lose anything. I actually lost the best job in the world.Darren Lehmann, on ABC Radio (via ABC News and ESPNcricinfo)
Greenberg says the quiet part
The bigger line of the day came from Cricket Australia's chief executive. Todd Greenberg told SEN Cricket, as ESPNcricinfo reported, that the episode is "very damaging for our sport" and that the 2018 investigation, rushed through before the Johannesburg Test, "clearly" had gaps.
He named no names, but he no longer pretends the original account stands. The independent forum CA announced this week will be led by someone from outside cricket, to be named next week with its terms of reference. Cummins, Bancroft and Lehmann have said they will take part. Nobody can be made to.
What we're finding out now, people didn't tell the truth at that period of time. Who's to say they'll tell the truth in 2026? I can't give you the answer.Todd Greenberg, to SEN Cricket (via ESPNcricinfo)
Lehmann's Australia in Tests, July 2013 to March 2018
| Tests | 58: won 30, lost 20, drawn 8 |
| At home | 26 Tests: won 19, lost 2, drawn 5 |
| Away | 32 Tests: won 11, lost 18, drawn 3 |
| Gqeberha (Port Elizabeth), Mar 9 2018 | Lost by 6 wickets |
| Cape Town, Mar 22 2018 | Lost by 322 runs |
| Johannesburg, Mar 30 2018 | Lost by 492 runs |
| Next Australia Test | v New Zealand, Perth Stadium, Dec 9 (07:50 IST) |
The CricIntel view
We pulled every Test from Lehmann's time in charge on Statsguru, and the numbers explain the pressure Bancroft describes better than any recollection. At home his Australia were close to unbeatable: 19 wins and two defeats in 26 Tests. Away they won 11 of 32 and lost 18. Abroad, with the ball going soft on dry pitches, the whole plan rested on reverse swing, which is exactly what Lehmann meant when he told ABC Radio "you're always trying to get the ball moving".
The second number is the one nobody in this saga mentions. The two Tests where sandpaper is now alleged, Port Elizabeth and Cape Town, Australia lost by six wickets and 322 runs. Then they lost Johannesburg by 492. Whatever was done to the ball, it bought nothing. A team that had led the series after Durban lost the next three Tests by a combined margin that no reverse-swing spell could hide.
That matters for 2026 because Greenberg has now said out loud that the 2018 version was not the full truth, and the forum cannot compel a single witness. Lehmann's "can't remember" leaves Bancroft's account of the tea break standing, neither confirmed nor knocked down. Expect the forum's chair and terms to dominate the next week, while Australia play four more T20Is against England before the Perth Test on December 9, 17 days from now. Cummins walks out there with the board's backing, and with his chief executive admitting the old story had holes in it.
Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?
Sources
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →