Marsh can skip the microphone. He cannot skip the question, and March is coming
Australia's T20I captain sat out the MCG press conference and plans to say nothing to the written press for five games, on the same day Greg Chappell asked for a proper inquiry into 2018. Silence is a plan for a fortnight. The questions have a deadline of their own.
An empty chair at the MCG
On the eve of the first T20I, England's captain Harry Brook sat in front of the media at the MCG and talked about good memories of the ground. Australia's captain did not turn up at all. As the Press Association reported, in a piece carried by The Independent, Mitchell Marsh took no part in Friday's pre-series press conferences, and the uncapped Victorian keeper Sam Harper fronted up instead.
It is not a one-off. PA understands Marsh intends to do no written media at all across the five-match series, and Sky Sports reported the same: no engagement with the written press during the T20 leg. Five games, twelve days, from Melbourne on November 21 to Canberra on December 2, and the home captain plans to answer nobody with a notebook.
The reason is obvious. Cameron Bancroft's account of 2018 names the bowlers he talked reverse swing with, and Marsh, who played all four Tests of that series according to ABC News, is one of them. He has not been accused of anything. He has also, very clearly, decided he is done talking about it.
I've personally moved on. This is my choice to not go back there. Who knows? Maybe I'll write a book one day.Mitchell Marsh, at last week's ODI press conference, as reported by ABC News
Chappell sets a clock
The same day, a former Australia captain made the silence harder to sustain. Writing in the Sydney Morning Herald, as The Independent reported, Greg Chappell called for a full independent inquiry into the scandal, with the whole touring party and support staff invited to give evidence and protection for anyone who tells the truth.
The key detail is the deadline. Chappell wants it finished by March, before the one-off 150th-anniversary Test against England at the MCG on March 11 to 15, and he wants interim findings published if it cannot finish in time. Cricket Australia's own plan, a forum reportedly led by a former judge with no new sanctions, does not go far enough for him.
CA's proposed forum, reportedly led by a former judge, with no new sanctions, is a start. But on its own, it won't restore trust.Greg Chappell, in the Sydney Morning Herald, as reported by The Independent
Brook gets the other half of the question
England have not escaped entirely. David Saker, Australia's bowling coach in 2018, has worked as a consultant for England, and Brook was asked about him on Friday. His answer was a polite shrug, and a fair one: he does not pick the coaches. ABC's roundup of who has said what also shows how split the 2018 group remains, with Khawaja, Warner and Bancroft on one side and the four bowlers who signed the 2021 denial, Starc, Cummins, Hazlewood and Lyon, on the other. Marsh's name is on neither list.
I haven't spoken to him but, again, I wasn't involved in that (Australian) dressing room.Harry Brook, England T20I captain, on David Saker, as reported by The Independent
The CricIntel view
Marsh's silence is understandable and, as a strategy, almost certainly wrong. It works for a fortnight. It does not work for a summer. Chappell's deadline is the 150th-anniversary Test, which is about 110 days after this first T20I, and Cricket Australia's forum, the Khawaja book and the Bancroft article are not going away in that time. Every week Marsh says nothing, the next question gets louder, and the first time Australia lose a close game this series, the empty chair becomes the story instead of the cricket.
There is also a cricket cost, and it is bigger than it looks. This is the thinnest Australian T20I side in years. Travis Head, Josh Inglis and Cameron Green are rested, Sky Sports reports that Mitchell Starc has retired from T20Is and Cummins and Hazlewood are rested, and our own preview had Adam Zampa as a fitness doubt with back spasms. In the CricIntel player database, Head alone carries 2,891 T20 runs at a strike rate of 163.89. Take him out and Marsh, with 4,111 runs in 143 T20 matches, is the most experienced batter in our possible XI, ahead of Tim David on 121 matches, and he has to be the senior voice too.
That is where the silence hurts. A young side with Harper on debut, Mitchell Owen and Jake Fraser-McGurk back, and two or three new bowlers needs a captain who sets the tone in public as well as in the huddle. Brook does that for England. His T20 strike rate of 159.75 in our database is about 15 points higher than Marsh's 144.86, and his side arrive having won their last three T20Is and the ODI series 2-1. Our preview already leaned to England, narrowly. If Marsh is not going to talk, he has to bat at something closer to Brook's tempo, because a slow captain's innings in a loss would hand the critics the line they want. The best answer Marsh can give this week is not a quote. It is 60 off 35 at the top on Saturday night.
The two captains, and who Australia are missing
| Mitchell Marsh, T20 record (CricIntel database) | 143 matches, 4,111 runs, avg 32.37, SR 144.86, 54 wickets |
| Harry Brook, T20 record (CricIntel database) | 72 matches, 1,885 runs, avg 34.27, SR 159.75 |
| Travis Head (rested) | 102 matches, 2,891 runs, SR 163.89 |
| Adam Zampa (fitness doubt) | 135 matches, 180 wickets, economy 7.54 |
| Also out for Australia | Inglis, Green rested; Cummins, Hazlewood rested; Starc retired from T20Is |
| T20I series | Five games, MCG November 21 to Canberra December 2 |
| Chappell's inquiry deadline | Before the 150th-anniversary Test, MCG, March 11 to 15 |
What to watch on Saturday
The toss and the post-match chat are broadcast, not written press, so Marsh will still be on camera twice on Saturday. Watch whether the broadcasters ask the question and whether he gives anything at all. On the field, watch the first six overs: with Head gone, Australia's powerplay depends on Harper, Fraser-McGurk and Marsh himself. If they get going, the conversation shifts to cricket for a few days. If they do not, nobody will be talking about the MCG's good memories.
Australia vs England, 1st T20I, Melbourne Cricket Ground, Saturday, November 21, 7:15 PM AEDT / 1:45 PM IST. Read our full match preview for possible XIs and the pitch report.
Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?
Sources
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →