Duffy didn't have a bad day. New Zealand gave him a bad job
Jacob Oram is right that one 1 for 180 doesn't undo two great seasons. But India took 38% of their runs from 23% of the overs, and the scorecard says the plan, not the bowler, is the thing to fix before Day 4.
When the third question about Jacob Duffy arrived at the Basin Reserve press conference on Saturday evening, Jacob Oram joked that it was "the Jacob Duffy hour", according to ESPNcricinfo's account. By the time he walked out, New Zealand's bowling coach had made his case: one expensive day does not erase two seasons of very good ones.
It was an expensive day. As UNI India reported from Wellington, India closed Day 3 of the first Test on 486 for 4, a lead of 118, with KL Rahul making 136 and captain Shubman Gill bowled by Duffy for 98 three balls from stumps. Duffy's figures read 29-1-180-1, with seven no-balls. That wicket was the best ball he bowled all day, and it came after India had already decided which end to attack.
He's had way too many good days in the last two seasons for one day to suddenly put him in the depths of despair. So he'll be okay.Jacob Oram, New Zealand bowling coach, as reported by ESPNcricinfo
What Oram said about the plan
The more revealing part of Oram's press conference, as ESPNcricinfo's report sets out, was about roles. Matt Henry and Kyle Jamieson shared the new ball, and Oram said Jamieson got the nod on the form he had carried through the white-ball series. Duffy, the quickest of the four at around 140kph, was the one asked to bowl short.
That had a knock-on effect. New Zealand have often had keeper Tom Blundell standing up to the seamers to pin batters in their crease. With Duffy's pace and the short-ball plan, Blundell stayed back, so India's batters could use the crease freely against him. Oram also pointed to the calendar: Duffy missed the England tour for the birth of his first child and has bowled mostly white-ball cricket since, where yorkers and slower balls take over from simply hitting a length.
Duff was the only one who implemented that short-ball plan. And obviously [you have to] stand back for that.Jacob Oram, as reported by ESPNcricinfo
One end leaked, three ends held: New Zealand's bowling in India's 486/4
| Jacob Duffy | 29-1-180-1, economy 6.20, 7 no-balls, dot balls 56.9% |
| Matt Henry | 29-7-86-1, economy 2.96, dot balls 73.0% |
| Kyle Jamieson | 27-6-57-1, economy 2.11, dot balls 77.2% |
| Nathan Smith | 24-4-65-1, economy 2.70, dot balls 81.3% |
| Henry, Jamieson and Smith combined | 80 overs, 208 runs, 3 wickets, economy 2.60 |
| Glenn Phillips (part-time spin) | 14 overs, 76 runs, 0 wickets |
| Duffy's share | 23.2% of the overs, 38.3% of the 470 runs charged to bowlers |
| Duffy in his 4 Tests before this one | 25 wickets at 16.28, economy 2.37, best 5/34 |
| No-balls in the innings | New Zealand 14 (Duffy 7), India 6 in New Zealand's 368 |
The CricIntel view
Oram is right about the bowler and too kind about the plan. Duffy came into this Test with 25 wickets in four Tests at 16.28 and an economy of 2.37. That is a new-ball swing bowler's record, built by pitching it up and moving it. In Wellington, New Zealand gave the new ball to Henry and Jamieson, then asked Duffy to be the enforcer on a flat deck, with the keeper back and the old ball. He was being used as the one thing his Test record says he is not.
India read it within a session. Look at the dot-ball rates: Smith 81.3%, Jamieson 77.2%, Henry 73.0%, Duffy 56.9%. Rahul and Devdutt Padikkal added 165 off 337 balls by blocking the three tight ends and scoring off the fourth. The 180 runs Duffy has conceded in one innings are 44% of the 407 he gave away across his whole Test career before this match.
The deeper problem is that New Zealand picked four seamers and Glenn Phillips' off-spin as the fifth option, so they effectively had three bowlers who could hold an end. Duffy and Phillips together: 43 overs, 256 runs, one wicket. Everyone else: 82 overs, 214 runs, three wickets.
For Day 4, the arithmetic now favours India but not by as much as 486 for 4 suggests. Our sum: India have scored at 3.89 an over, so another 25 overs would push the lead past 200, which still leaves New Zealand roughly 150 overs to survive across two days. They lasted 121 overs in the first innings. If Gill declares too late, the draw is real. The quickest way for New Zealand to save this Test is not a pep talk for Duffy; it is letting him pitch the ball up again, at the stumps, the way he took those 25 wickets.
Where the Test stands after Day 3
| New Zealand 1st innings | 368 all out (121 overs): Henry Nicholls 175*, Glenn Phillips 118; Jasprit Bumrah 4/92 |
| India 1st innings | 486 for 4 (125 overs): KL Rahul 136 (290 balls), Shubman Gill 98 (146), Yashasvi Jaiswal 85 (89), Devdutt Padikkal 80 (175), Rishabh Pant 55* (62) |
| Lead | India by 118, six wickets in hand |
| Run rate | India 3.89 an over, New Zealand 3.04 |
| Big stands | Rahul and Padikkal 165 (337 balls), Gill and Pant 100 (129), Jaiswal and Rahul 130 (170) |
What to watch on Sunday
Two things. First, whether Rishabh Pant, 55 off 62, is told to go for it from the first over, because India's whole route to a win runs through time, not runs. Second, which end Duffy starts from and with what length. Oram told reporters Duffy is always working on his run-up, his delivery stride and his wrist position. The bigger tweak is in the captain's hands: let him bowl full and give Blundell a reason to stand up again.
Three balls before stumps, Duffy bowled Gill with a length ball that seamed back in. That is the bowler New Zealand need on Day 4. They just have to ask for him.
Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?
Sources
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →