Gavaskar defends Siraj, but India's Wellington snubs were the numbers talking
Siraj and Jadeja both sat out the Basin Reserve Test, and Sunil Gavaskar is not happy about one of them. The 2026 figures and Jadeja's record in New Zealand explain the calls. Day 1 shows the one place the plan is leaking.
Two big names on the bench
India won the toss in Wellington on Thursday, bowled first on a green Basin Reserve pitch, and left two of their most familiar Test faces out of the XI. Mohammed Siraj made way for the debutant Anshul Kamboj. Ravindra Jadeja lost his spot to Washington Sundar, picked as the only spinner.
ESPNcricinfo called the Siraj omission debatable and the Jadeja one "a bit of a shock", and noted that the thinking appears to centre on New Zealand's four left-handers at the top: Tom Latham, Devon Conway, Henry Nicholls and Rachin Ravindra. India went with four specialist quicks, Jasprit Bumrah, Prasidh Krishna, Kamboj and Akash Deep, rather than a batting allrounder at No. 8.
We were contemplating for the past week which combination to go with because all of our fast bowlers have been doing really well. Very difficult for Siraj and Gurnoor for both of them to miss out.Shubman Gill, at the toss, via ANI (The Tribune)
Gavaskar is not buying it
Sunil Gavaskar, on Sony Sports and as reported by Daijiworld, said he had seen the hints, since Siraj was not sent to the Test camp early, but still called the decision a surprise. He said nothing has gone wrong with Siraj's rhythm.
Scott Styris, on the same broadcast, took the other side and backed Kamboj for the movement on offer, per the same report.
I don't think he has let India down. He has never let India down. Why he has not been picked is something I don't know. I only hope the others who have been picked ahead of him deliver.Sunil Gavaskar, on Sony Sports, via Daijiworld
The numbers behind both omissions (Statsguru, Tests)
| Siraj in SENA countries | 91 wickets in 23 Tests |
| Siraj in 2025 | 43 wickets at 27.2 in 10 Tests |
| Siraj in 2026 | 5 wickets at 28.6 in 3 Tests, strike rate 68.4 |
| Prasidh in 2026 before Wellington | 10 wickets for 215 runs in 3 Tests (average 21.50) |
| Jadeja at home / away | average 20.95 / 36.67 |
| Jadeja in New Zealand | 5 wickets at 60.6 in 3 Tests, strike rate 124.8 |
| Washington v New Zealand | 16 wickets at 15.31 in 3 Tests, best 7/59 |
| Jadeja's Test batting in 2025 | 764 runs at 63.66, 2 hundreds |
The CricIntel view
Gavaskar is right about the past and wrong about the present. Siraj's 91 wickets in 23 SENA Tests are a genuine overseas record, and 43 wickets in 2025 made him India's workhorse. But 2026 has been thin: 5 wickets in 3 Tests, one every 68.4 balls. Prasidh, the man he is really competing with for the fourth seamer's role, went into this Test with 10 wickets for 215 in his 3 Tests this year. On this year's form alone, the selectors picked the in-form bowler.
Jadeja is the harder call, and the answer is that his ball has never travelled to New Zealand. Statsguru has him on 5 wickets at 60.6 in 3 Tests here, a wicket every 124.8 balls, and his away average of 36.67 is far from his 20.95 at home. Washington's 16 wickets at 15.31 against New Zealand came almost entirely in India in 2024, so that number flatters him, but the off-spinner turning the ball away from four left-handers is a real tactical edge, not a hunch.
What India have given up is runs. Jadeja made 764 at 63.66 with 2 hundreds in 2025. Leaving him out with Pant just back from injury puts more of the lower-order weight on Washington and Jurel.
And Day 1 has already found the soft spot. At the time of writing New Zealand were 192/5 after 63.3 overs, with Nicholls on 87 and Phillips on 69 not out. Bumrah has 3/48 from 16 overs, Akash Deep 1/33 and Kamboj 1/39 on debut. Prasidh, the pick ahead of Siraj, has 0/48 from 11, the most expensive of the four quicks at 4.36 an over. Washington has bowled only 8.3 overs. If Prasidh stays wicketless through this innings, Siraj's case for Christchurch on November 27 writes itself, and Gavaskar gets his "I told you so" a week late.
India's bowling, Day 1 at the Basin Reserve (live, at 192/5)
| Jasprit Bumrah | 16-5-48-3 |
| Anshul Kamboj (debut) | 13-3-39-1 |
| Akash Deep | 15-5-33-1 |
| Prasidh Krishna | 11-1-48-0 |
| Washington Sundar | 8.3-1-19-0 |
| Four seamers combined | 55 overs, 5 for 168 |
What to watch next
Two things settle this argument before Christchurch. First, whether Washington gets a proper bowl at the left-handers once the ball is older, because a spinner who sends down 8.3 overs on a first day is not the reason he was picked. Second, whether Prasidh can find the wickets that Kamboj and Akash Deep already have. If both answers are no, expect Siraj and probably Jadeja back at Hagley Oval.
Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?
Sources
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →