Stars Beat Thunder by 6 Runs at Drummoyne: Prestwidge's 5 for 25 Defends 120 as Sydney Lose 7 for 26
On a ground where 180 had been chased this season, the Stars made only 120 for 8. The Thunder were 88 for 3 with more than five overs left and needing 33. Then Georgia Prestwidge took five wickets, Sydney were all out for 114, and the Stars won for the first time since opening night.
Some totals are defended by a bowling plan. This one was defended by a few minutes of panic, and the Stars were the side that kept their heads. Sent in at Drummoyne Oval, a ground that had given up 184, 183 and 180 this season, the Melbourne Stars could make only 120 for 8. At 88 for 3 in the 15th over, Sydney Thunder needed 33 from 34 balls with seven wickets in hand. It should have been a stroll.
It was not. Georgia Prestwidge took 5 for 25, the Thunder lost their last seven wickets for 26 runs, and they were all out for 114 with three balls unused. The Stars, who had lost five in a row since beating the Hurricanes on opening night, have their second win. The Thunder, who won their first two games, have now lost four on the trot.
Match Summary
| Melbourne Stars | 120/8 (20 overs): Meg Lanning 28 (23, 2 fours, 1 six), Naomi Stalenberg 27 (26, 3 fours), Kim Garth 19* (12), Amy Jones 13 (12, 3 fours), Dani Gibson 7 (13), Rhys McKenna 7* (8), Georgia Prestwidge 6 (9), Charlie Dean 4 (7) |
| Thunder bowling | Nicola Hancock 4-0-17-4, Nadine de Klerk 3-0-13-2, Samantha Bates 4-0-23-2, Georgia Voll 3-0-18-0, Jemma Barsby 2-0-13-0, Lauren Bell 4-0-32-0 |
| Sydney Thunder | 114 all out (19.3 overs): Anika Learoyd 33 (42, 2 fours), Tahlia Wilson 21 (25, 3 fours), Georgia Voll 14 (8), Laura Harris 12 (8), Nadine de Klerk 10 (6), Heather Knight 9 (11), Phoebe Litchfield 1 (4) |
| Stars bowling | Georgia Prestwidge 4-0-25-5, Kim Garth 4-0-20-2, Dani Gibson 4-0-17-2, Charlie Dean 3.3-0-15-1, Rhys McKenna 2-0-22-0, Sophie Day 2-0-14-0 |
| Collapse | Thunder from 88/3 (14.2 overs) to 114 all out (19.3): 7 wickets for 26 |
| Result | Melbourne Stars won by 6 runs |
| Toss | Sydney Thunder, chose to field |
| Player of the Match | Georgia Prestwidge (Melbourne Stars) |
| Venue | Drummoyne Oval, Sydney |
The Stars' batting never settled. Amy Jones hit three fours in her 13 before she was caught off Samantha Bates in the third over, and Nadine de Klerk removed Carly Leeson lbw and then bowled Meg Lanning for 28, so the captain who came into the game as the Stars' leading run-scorer was gone in the ninth over at 53 for 4. Naomi Stalenberg's 27 held the middle together, but at 95 for 8 after 17 overs a total of even 110 looked uncertain. Kim Garth and Rhys McKenna then added 25 unbroken off the last 18 balls, Garth making 19 off 12. Those runs turned out to be the margin, and then some.
With the ball, Garth set the tone. She had Phoebe Litchfield stumped by Jones in the first over and later had Georgia Voll caught behind after Voll had hit a four and a six in an eight-ball 14. Dani Gibson's four overs went for only 17 and she took the key wicket of Anika Learoyd. And Charlie Dean finished it with a return catch to remove Lauren Bell. It was a complete bowling effort from a side whose bowlers had struggled to defend totals for a fortnight.
For 14 overs the chase was under control. The Thunder were 65 for 3 at the halfway mark, and Learoyd and Tahlia Wilson added 38 to take them to 88 for 3. Then Prestwidge had Wilson caught by Dean for 21, Gibson had Learoyd caught by Dean for 33 an over later, and suddenly two new batters were facing a rising run rate. Laura Harris hit two fours in 12 off 8 before Prestwidge had her caught, Gibson bowled de Klerk, and Prestwidge bowled both Nicola Hancock and Jemma Barsby. From 88 for 3, the Thunder were 114 for 9, and Dean ended it in the 20th over.
The Thunder bowled very well, which makes this harder to take. Hancock's 4 for 17 and de Klerk's 2 for 13 in three overs had kept the Stars to 120. But a side that chased 178 at this ground earlier in the season lost seven wickets for 26 needing a run a ball. That is not a skill problem. It is what four close defeats in a row can do to a dressing room, and it will be the thing the Thunder most need to fix.
This was not the Drummoyne of earlier in the season. Our preview expected a true surface and a par of around 170; instead only 234 runs were scored in nearly 40 overs and 18 wickets fell. Most of the damage was done by bowlers taking pace off and hitting the stumps: four batters were bowled. The Thunder chose to bowl first, which was a fair reading of the ground's history, but on this night the side batting first had the advantage of not having to chase.
Prestwidge had already removed Heather Knight, caught by Garth in the eighth over, but her real work came later. When she came back the Thunder were on top, and between the 15th and 19th overs she took four more: Wilson and Harris caught trying to hit through the line, Hancock and Barsby bowled. She went for only 25 in her four overs while the batters were trying to get on with it, and that is the part of a spell that never makes the highlights. If a game can turn on one bowler, this one turned on her.
We leaned towards the Thunder, narrowly, and got it wrong. We named Lanning and Jones as the batters who could take the game away; between them they made 41, and the Stars won anyway, with the ball. We named Annabel Sutherland as the bowler the Stars most needed, and she did not feature; Prestwidge, whom we listed in the Stars' possible XI but did not single out, won the match. We also expected a batting pitch at Drummoyne and a par score near 170. On both counts the night told a different story, and we will own that.
The win lifts the Stars to four points from seven games, level on points with the Thunder, who stay sixth on a better net run rate. The Thunder are back in action against the Brisbane Heat on November 19 and then the Hobart Hurricanes on November 21. The Stars play the Melbourne Renegades on November 22, and they will go into that derby with something they have not had for a fortnight: a win to build on.
Want data-backed predictions for every IPL 2026 match?
Free to play
Wanna beat your friends?
Call the toss, the winner and the top scorer. Beat the AI. Climb the leaderboard.
Up to 90 points a match
Play Game →